You can in principle establish the gender-neutral criteria for your job classification yourself. There is no requirement anywhere to have this done by an external provider, and for a company with a manageable number of roles, it is in theory a matter of naming factors and applying them consistently. Where it gets stuck in practice is not the establishment itself but demonstrating that the criteria are genuinely gender-neutral and have been used in the same way across all roles.
Gender-neutral criteria means that the characteristics you use to evaluate roles are independent of who performs the role. Common factors in job evaluation are knowledge and skills, responsibility, effort and working conditions. These are not invented concepts but building blocks that appear in virtually every job evaluation system. The question is not whether you use these factors, but whether weighting them does not incidentally favour roles that are predominantly performed by one gender.
What doing it yourself means in practice
Doing it yourself means that you apply the same factors for each role, document the weighting in writing, and can explain that weighting without falling back on "that's how we do things here". That last part is precisely where things often go wrong: criteria that once grew intuitively turn out not to be applied consistently everywhere when tested. An installation company that weighs physical effort heavily in technical roles but hardly at all in administrative roles must be able to explain why that weighting is objectively justified and does not incidentally coincide with a gender distribution.
The second practical requirement is traceability. Once an employee submits an information request or once the reporting obligation comes into view, you must be able to show on the basis of which criteria roles have been marked as equivalent. This is not a snapshot but a document you must be able to update if roles change. Anyone maintaining this in a spreadsheet that no one else understands runs the risk that the supporting documentation will not be complete or available in time when a request comes in.
Where doing it yourself has limits
The boundary between doing it yourself and outsourcing is not about whether it is permitted, but about whether you can systematically maintain it across all roles, departments and future adjustments. With a handful of roles that is manageable. Once the number of roles grows, or once roles have to be compared across different countries, the risk increases that criteria start to differ unnoticed between departments or locations. That is the moment when a structured system makes a difference: not because it judges whether a difference is justified, but because it applies the same criteria consistently and documents who made which choice and when.
It is also important to understand what doing it yourself does not solve. Whether a pay difference between equivalent roles is justified is not a question that a criteria list answers — that is a judgment that lies with you, your legal adviser or the competent supervisory authority. A system, whether self-made or supported, structures and documents; it does not make a judgment. In the knowledge base with explanations per topic you will find how job evaluation relates to the reporting obligation and the right to information, so you get a more complete picture of what will be needed next.
How you determine what works for your situation
The choice between doing it yourself and outsourcing mainly depends on the number of roles, the expectation that those roles will change, and the question of whether you are already comparing across EU countries. A small, stable organization with few role categories can set the criteria well enough on its own, provided this is done in writing and consistently. Once the number of roles, locations, or classifications increases, it becomes more attractive to have the criteria structured in a fixed system, if only to prevent the rationale from being interpreted differently by different employees.
Via the compliance check that maps out your situation in a few questions you can see which obligations already apply to your company now and which only come into play with a larger number of employees. On the page about where our information comes from you can see how we keep criteria and classifications traceable back to the official text, and on the overview of what the system around role classification costs you can see what changes if you no longer want to maintain the documentation yourself.
If you are unsure whether your current criteria are set out consistently enough, start with the free compliance check. It gives you an indication of where you stand in a few minutes, without needing to create an account.