The most common mistake in salary history ban compliance is not that an employer asks directly what a candidate currently earns. Almost everyone knows how to avoid that by now. The mistake lies in the workaround: the question is asked through an application form with a mandatory 'current salary' field, through an external recruiter who asks anyway, or through a question about 'salary expectations' that in practice yields the same answer.
The salary history ban applies without any threshold, regardless of your organization's size, and it applies throughout the entire recruitment process: from the job posting to the final interview. This means that indirect forms of the question may also fall under the ban. It is not about the exact wording, but about what is actually being gathered: information about the candidate's current or previous salary.
Where things go wrong in practice
In most cases, the mistake is not with the recruiter at the table, but with the system around it. An ATS template with a mandatory field, an intake form that has been used unchanged for years, or a checklist for a telephone pre-screening: they are often older than the rule and rarely reviewed on this point. No one deliberately added the question, but no one removed it either.
A second recurring pattern is asking about 'salary expectations' without context. In itself, asking someone what they want to earn in the new role is not a problem; that concerns the future. But in practice, interviewers often phrase that question in a way that makes the answer inevitably reveal the current salary, for example by asking for a percentage increase compared to 'what you have now'.
External recruiters and the salary history ban
Employers who recruit through an agency or independent recruiter often assume that the ban applies only to them, not to the party conducting the intake on their behalf. This is a misconception that leads to problems in practice: if a recruiter asks the question on your instruction, that question is effectively asked on behalf of your company. It is therefore worthwhile to explicitly include this in your instructions to an agency, rather than assuming it will work out on its own.
The same applies to assessments and pre-screening tools provided by a third party. If such a tool automatically displays a salary field to the candidate, that is just as much a question asked on your behalf, even if no one at your company clicked on the field.
What a good job posting actually asks
The salary history ban does not stand alone. It is connected to the obligation to provide a salary range in the job posting yourself, so that the candidate knows within what margin they can negotiate without having to disclose their current salary first. A job posting that lacks this salary range and then asks about current salary anyway to get an indication, is in fact stacking two separate issues on top of each other. With a few questions about your own job posting you can quickly see whether both points are in order.
How to prevent it
The most practical approach is to review the recruitment process itself, not just the job posting. Look at the ATS form, the question list for a telephone intake, the briefing to an external agency, and the questions a hiring manager typically asks. Replace each field or question that (even implicitly) gathers current or previous salary information with a question that focuses only on the future role.
Because this rule is connected to other obligations that apply without a threshold, such as the salary range in the job posting and the requirement that selection criteria are gender-neutral, it is useful to view them in relation to one another rather than in isolation. The knowledge base with the topics explained per situation sets these obligations side by side, with the location in the official text included. If you have doubts about a specific wording in your own process, that is something to discuss with a legal advisor or the competent supervisory authority; payria.eu structures and flags issues, but does not make judgments about individual texts or procedures.
For more background on how this information is structured and where it comes from, read the page on how the information is created. If you want to know where your own recruitment process stands within half an hour, take the free quick-scan or browse through the topics in the knowledge base.